CNHI News Service


February 19, 2013

Torture is best left to the movies

AMESBURY, Mass. — The film “Zero Dark Thirty” has certainly stirred up plenty of

criticism. Early scenes depict torture performed by the CIA to get
information as to the whereabouts of Osama bin Laden. Did torture produce
that intelligence?

Better filmmakers than Kathryn Bigelow and Mark Boal would explore the

philosophical and legal implications of torture. “Zero Dark Thirty” is
just Call of Duty, the video game, on steroids -- a single-line pursuit of
bin Laden. Bigelow’s previous films have always sacrificed nuance and
rumination for extreme violence with the exception, ironically, of the
war movie “The Hurt Locker,” her best picture Oscar winner, which was more
character driven.

Critics have taken “Zero Dark Thirty” to task for insinuating that torture led to bin Laden. Of course, to say this is to say torture works, which means the U.S. was justified in waterboarding and black-site renditions.

Former CIA director Leon Panetta said recently that there is “no question
that some of the intelligence gathered was a result of some of these
methods” before admitting that bin Laden probably would’ve been found
without enhanced interrogation.

But this is problematic if we are to believe what the Bush administration told us. The official line was that only three people were waterboarded, the last one being in 2003. There were certainly other kinds of torture used, which can be seen in the infamous photos from Abu Ghraib.

President Obama put an end to torture when he took office in 2009. So
we’re to believe that intelligence gathered in 2003 via waterboarding
finally resulted in bin Laden’s demise eight years later? That seems
ridiculous. It’s a safe bet that bin Laden was taken down through
old-fashioned detective work and not waterboarding.

For the sake of argument, however, let’s assume “Zero Dark Thirty” and Panetta are correct in saying torture led to bin Laden. Maybe it did. It would be hard for the purveyors of torture in the Bush administration to admit that torture did no good. The chief architect of using torture was John Yoo, assistant U.S. Attorney General in the Office of Legal Counsel under Bush. 

Text Only
  • taylor.armerding.jpg Zamperini, the Olympian and POW, was a hero because of his faith

    Louis Zamperini collected many accolades as an Olympic distance runner and brave bombardier who spent a month adrift at sea and two years in a Japanese prisoner of war camp. But faith and forgiveness are what truly distinguished him.

    July 18, 2014 1 Photo

  • Hobby Lobby critics push specious privacy pitch

    The violation of privacy argument by liberal detractors of the Supreme Court's decision in the Hobby Lobby-Obamacare case doesn't hold water when you consider the current collection and use of the personal details of your medical preferences.

    July 11, 2014

  • taylor.armerding.jpg Declare your independence from empty slogans

    'Independence Day' is now an ironic celebration in a country where the president promotes government dependence over actual freedom, and where bumper-sticker slogans have replaced actual, independent thought.

    July 3, 2014 1 Photo

  • taylor.armerding.jpg Taxi owners, government patrons try forcing Uber to go 'off-duty'

    Uber gives urban passengers an enticing alternative. Rides on-demand arrive faster than taxis, are cheaper and cleaner, and get rated by customers. Rather than hail innovation, government enablers are helping the heavily regulated taxicab industry freeze out the upstart.

    June 27, 2014 1 Photo

  • taylor.armerding.jpg IRS spins email yarn as Obama slips past another scandal

    Forget everything you've heard about email. All digital trace of a former IRS official's email over the 25 months the agency harassed conservative groups has mysteriously, improbably vanished. Gone, too, is the White House's accountability as President Obama slips from another scandal.

    June 20, 2014 1 Photo

  • taylor.armerding.jpg Obama: Don't listen to those who knew Bergdahl best

    The Obama administration chides anyone who suggests that Army Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl - the POW traded for a dream team of Taliban terrorists - might be something less than a hero. The White House wants us to stop jumping to conclusions - unless, of course, we're jumping to the right conclusions.

    June 13, 2014 1 Photo

  • taylor.armerding.jpg Left tallies 'true cost' of coal with a political calculator

    Weighing the "true cost" of coal-based energy is politically convenient. In a "true cost" world, coal may be more expensive but alternate energies aren't affordable, either; you don't get a tax break on your mortgage; and the feds don't protect the United Auto Workers from Chrysler's bankruptcy.

    June 6, 2014 1 Photo

  • taylor.armerding.jpg Veterans wait for healthcare, we wait for accountability

    Poor care and long wait times at the Veterans Administration are little surprise for an organization with such an entrenched bureaucracy. It's almost predictable as the Obama administration's mock surprise and non-response.

    May 30, 2014 1 Photo

  • taylor.armerding.jpg Reality replaces Obama's foreign policy promises

    Terrorists were supposed to disappear and tensions would dissolve between the United States and other countries when President Barack Obama took office. But prize-winning promises don't hold up to real-life Chinese hackers, attacks on U.S. diplomats and Russian land grabs.

    May 23, 2014 1 Photo

  • sampollak.jpg Presidential perk turned into a bummer

    Who wants to be president of the United States if you don't get time to actually linger and soak in the Baseball Hall of Fame?

    May 23, 2014 1 Photo