CNHI News Service


February 19, 2013

Torture is best left to the movies

AMESBURY, Mass. — The film “Zero Dark Thirty” has certainly stirred up plenty of

criticism. Early scenes depict torture performed by the CIA to get
information as to the whereabouts of Osama bin Laden. Did torture produce
that intelligence?

Better filmmakers than Kathryn Bigelow and Mark Boal would explore the

philosophical and legal implications of torture. “Zero Dark Thirty” is
just Call of Duty, the video game, on steroids -- a single-line pursuit of
bin Laden. Bigelow’s previous films have always sacrificed nuance and
rumination for extreme violence with the exception, ironically, of the
war movie “The Hurt Locker,” her best picture Oscar winner, which was more
character driven.

Critics have taken “Zero Dark Thirty” to task for insinuating that torture led to bin Laden. Of course, to say this is to say torture works, which means the U.S. was justified in waterboarding and black-site renditions.

Former CIA director Leon Panetta said recently that there is “no question
that some of the intelligence gathered was a result of some of these
methods” before admitting that bin Laden probably would’ve been found
without enhanced interrogation.

But this is problematic if we are to believe what the Bush administration told us. The official line was that only three people were waterboarded, the last one being in 2003. There were certainly other kinds of torture used, which can be seen in the infamous photos from Abu Ghraib.

President Obama put an end to torture when he took office in 2009. So
we’re to believe that intelligence gathered in 2003 via waterboarding
finally resulted in bin Laden’s demise eight years later? That seems
ridiculous. It’s a safe bet that bin Laden was taken down through
old-fashioned detective work and not waterboarding.

For the sake of argument, however, let’s assume “Zero Dark Thirty” and Panetta are correct in saying torture led to bin Laden. Maybe it did. It would be hard for the purveyors of torture in the Bush administration to admit that torture did no good. The chief architect of using torture was John Yoo, assistant U.S. Attorney General in the Office of Legal Counsel under Bush. 

Text Only
  • taylor.armerding.jpg Warren's populist pitch on student loans is off key

    Sen. Elizabeth Warren's populist rhetoric pumps up students about their loan burdens, but she conveniently neglects to mention the real problem - the exorbitant cost of college - much less how she's benefitted from those high prices.

    April 18, 2014 1 Photo

  • taylor.armerding.jpg Obama's equal pay exaggeration leads us all into danger

    The president's claims of national shame over gender-based pay inequity spring from distorted calculations, as well as some convenient political math.

    April 11, 2014 1 Photo

  • taylor.armerding.jpg Voters beware of oligarchs and bogeymen

    Scaring voters to distract them from issues is a tired - and bipartisan - ploy sure to be in heavy rotation this campaign season.

    April 4, 2014 1 Photo

  • taylor.armerding.jpg Put teens to work by laying off minimum wage rhetoric

    Idle teen workers may be a national problem, but frugal private employers aren't the reason for it. Minimum wage hikes - like the one championed by President Obama - squeeze these marginal jobs out of the economy.

    March 28, 2014 1 Photo

  • taylor.armerding.jpg Legal marijuana can be government's new cash crop

    Officials holding out against legalized marijuana may "evolve" their thinking because of one number: Colorado says it gathered $2 million in taxes from pot shops in January, as business was just getting started.

    March 21, 2014 1 Photo

  • taylor.armerding.jpg Banning a 'B-word' teaches girls the wrong lesson

    Striking the word "bossy" from the language doesn't help young girls learn to speak up or become leaders. It teaches them how to be, well, bossy.

    March 14, 2014 1 Photo

  • taylor.armerding.jpg Giving businesses choice is not legalizing discrimination

    The owner of a California gay bar should be allowed to refuse service to legislators he considers "crazy, ignorant or stupid." The problem is the popular double-standard that supports his version of "discrimination" while raging against anyone who disagrees with him but wants the same freedom.

    March 7, 2014 1 Photo

  • taylor.armerding.jpg Obama twists Constitution to cut U.S. military

    President Obama's plan to slash the military to pre-World War II levels endangers the country, especially when our enemies don't know the war is over.

    February 28, 2014 1 Photo

  • taylor.armerding.jpg Benefits of hiking minimum wage are an illusion

    The president's latest economic fantasy says raising the minimum wage will incentivize work, lower unemployment, juice the economy and may even lower taxes. All while businesses swallow billions of dollars more in labor costs.

    February 21, 2014 1 Photo

  • taylor.armerding.jpg Coastal residents should pay true cost of flood insurance

    The environmental champions in Congress took a big break from their moral scolding this past month with a gigantic “Never mind!” after their constituents discovered the law requiring them to start paying the true cost of living in flood-prone areas.

    February 14, 2014 1 Photo