CNHI News Service

Opinion

December 18, 2012

Will another shooting rampage matter?

 

It’s my expectation that last week’s deadly school shooting in Connecticut will produce a series of predictable results.

We’ll see the outpourings of grief and expressions of outrage. Less visible will be the struggles of families who lost loved ones and are trying to cope with the horror thrust upon them.

The ongoing police investigation will piece much of the story together. It will paint a picture of the killer and perhaps even develop a motive for why he went into an elementary school and took 26 lives before killing himself.

But there is no real motive for such a crime. It is an act of inexplicable insanity, the product of a disturbed mind most likely driven by an inner rage that strives to inflict as much pain as possible before ending it all.

As with any such tragedy, there will be moves across the county to beef up security at schools. Presumably, this will come at a significant expense many school districts can’t afford.

There will be steps taken based on the idea that quick action could prevent the loss of life. For instance, just east of us, school officials in the Butler (Pa.) Area School District have voted to arm their security guards.

This is supposed to provide a measure of comfort, but it doesn’t take much imagination to envision things going wrong once guns are introduced to crowded school buildings, past the metal detectors designed to thwart them.

Yet there have been calls — including from at least one member of Congress — to arm school officials. The idea is that once an intruder shows up with a gun, people trained to diagram sentences or solve geometry problems will quickly convert to Rambos, taking out the bad guys.

Such arguments operate from a fantasy view of the world, based more on myth and movie-making than any grasp of reality. Despite the prevalence of guns in America, these shooters typically take their own lives or else they are captured alive. Armed private citizens don’t save the day.

And that gets us to the topic of gun control, which already has surfaced in the public debate over the Connecticut shooting. It got a push from President Obama, who made an oblique reference to it in his comments following the rampage.

This is the same Obama who studiously avoided the subject of gun control in this year’s presidential campaign.

So there will be demands for tough action to control ownership of guns, or at least some guns or their accessories with some people. On the other side will be those who say it’s unfair to law-abiding citizens to restrict their constitutional access to firearms because of the actions of the emotionally deranged.

The practical result of any debates over gun control these days appears to be no legislative action, just a big rush to buy more guns. Calls for added gun restrictions seem to be the best advertising possible for manufacturers and marketers.

Maybe there will be discussion about identifying and treating the mentally ill. Yet the track record here is minimal talk and no real action.

In the end, I suspect things won’t change much as a result of these shootings. More money will be spent on security, which may indeed stop attacks in some places.

But the people determined to act out in this manner have plenty of soft targets to choose from. If it’s not a school, it will be somewhere else. Security is a feel-good measure of limited value. Against a determined madman with lots of firepower, it provides no solution.

---

Mitchel Olszak is a columnist for the New Castle (Pa.) News.

Text Only
Opinion
  • EDITORIAL: Seizure of AP phone records an insult to independent press

    The government's secret examintion of phone records of Associated Press reporters and editors amounted to spying on an American news organization -- common practice in dictatorships but scary conduct in a democratic system that prizes an independent, watchdog press.

    May 15, 2013

  • keith.kappes.jpg Uncle Ed: Vain as a peacock, cool as a cucumber

    He was smart and worked hard to improve his mind, his physical skills and, most of all, his personal appearance.

    May 17, 2013 1 Photo

  • EDITORIALS: SEC, Wall Street too cozy; Clean up the IRS

    The Securities and Exchange Commission is too cozy with Wall Street deal makers; Mistakes made by the IRS must be cleaned up immediately.

    May 17, 2013

  • taylor.armerding.jpg Obama out to pass the blame once again

    For once, President Obama knows he can’t get away with pointing at George W. Bush. This mess – three of them actually – belongs to him.

    May 17, 2013 1 Photo

  • Marta.Mossburg.jpg Oops, maybe government is tyrannical

    What makes the IRS’s actions even worse is that top officials knew about the inappropriate questioning of conservative groups since 2011 but didn’t say anything about it to Congress.

    May 16, 2013 1 Photo

  • cary.brunswick.jpg We've become our own worst enemies

    While the chaotic phenomena at that time may have led to the development of the earliest forms of life, the levels of pollution we have put into the atmosphere today may contribute to an end of life for many species.

    May 15, 2013 1 Photo

  • EDITORIALS: Big Brother in D.C.; Sexual assault in the military

    Big Brother is alive and well in Washington, stomping on the rights of individuals and journalistic organizations;  No longer are soft apologies enough when women in the military report cases of sexual assault by their superiors.

     

    May 15, 2013

  • nick.massey.jpg Economic news just doesn't add up

    Stability creates its own instability. It is a weird statement, but it has a lot of power. Economist Hyman Minsky, who has been described as a post Keynesian, described the process well.

    May 15, 2013 1 Photo

  • steve.dicki.jpg Heritage Foundation's credibility takes a blow

     Jason Richwine, a Heritage Foundation ”scholar,” was let go after his Harvard dissertation came to light that
    said any immigration policy needs to take into consideration that Hispanics just aren’t as smart as whites.

    May 14, 2013 1 Photo

  • keith.kappes.jpg Flashbacks revive memories of a tragedy

    A man was screaming into a police radio as the Ohio River bridge between Point Pleasant, W.Va., and Gallipolis, Ohio, broke apart and dropped into the water in front of his disbelieving eyes.

    May 14, 2013 1 Photo

News
Sports

Features